VEGAS MYTHS BUSTED: The El Cortez Invented the Vegas Casino Buffet

Historian Hal Rothman, writing in his 2002 book Neon Metropolis, credits casino executive Davie Berman and chef Nat Hart with introducing the Las Vegas casino buffet at the El Cortez around 1945. The Jewish-style spread reportedly featured lox, whitefish, herring, and other traditional foods.

“A Las Vegas tradition, the buffet, was born,” Rothman wrote.

There is, however, a much better-documented candidate, whose buffet is already credited by most experts as the town’s first.

The Chuck Wagon opened at the El Rancho Vegas, the first casino resort on the Strip, in November 1946. It cost only $1.25, and unlimited coffee, as noted by the sign in this photo, was free. (Image: UNLV Special Collections)

Smorgasbord of Baloney

On Nov. 21, 1946, the Las Vegas Review-Journal reported that the Chuck Wagon buffet had held its grand opening at the El Rancho Vegas the previous night, attended by local dignitaries. The newspaper described it as a regular nightly feature, served from 1 a.m. to 4 a.m., followed by a complimentary breakfast served from 4 a.m. to 6 a.m.

The Chuck Wagon helped establish the late-night buffet model that other Strip casinos quickly copied. Less than three weeks after its debut, the Last Frontier introduced a $1.80 midnight buffet with a floor show.

Herb McDonald, the El Rancho’s publicity director, later claimed he came up with the idea accidentally while assembling cold cuts and cheese for a late-night snack.

“Gamblers walking by said they were hungry, and the buffet was born,” he is quoted as having said in his 2002 obituary.

The only other earlier close contender was a “Saturday Night Snack Bar” from 12:30 a.m.-2:30 a.m. at the Last Frontier. The casino advertised it in the R-J as far back as March 1943. But a snack bar isn’t necessarily a buffet, and the advertisement doesn’t establish that it offered an all-you-can-eat spread.

Rothman’s earlier El Cortez claim faces a chronological problem, too.

Facts Not on the Menu

In a 2014 oral-history interview archived at UNLV, Nat Hart’s son Steven recalled that his father came to Las Vegas with Davie Berman to help reopen the Flamingo after Bugsy Siegel’s June 1947 murder.

Chef Nat Hart sipping from a saucepot in a backyard circa 1950. (Image: UNLV Special Collections)

UNLV’s archival records also place Hart’s move to Las Vegas after Rothman’s proposed 1945 buffet date. A biographical note in the finding aid for the Nat Hart Professional Papers says he moved to Las Vegas in 1947. A separate biography in UNLV’s Southern Nevada Jewish Community Digital Heritage Project says he arrived in 1949. Both identify the Flamingo as his first Las Vegas employer.

By the way, Steven Hart’s recollection gets the Flamingo’s chronology wrong. It never closed and reopened after Siegel’s murder. It closed on Feb. 6, 1947 and reopened on March 1 of that same year, more than three months before his murder.

None of this proves Hart never visited Las Vegas earlier or couldn’t have once put out a buffet at the El Cortez before the El Rancho’s Chuck Wagon opened. But for Rothman’s account to be correct, Hart would have had to have:

  1. Visited Las Vegas before his documented relocation.
  2. Helped create a buffet for which no contemporary evidence has surfaced
  3. Done so for a casino that doesn’t even appear in his employment history.

Possible? Yes. Supported by the historical record? Not even close.

The El Cortez, which opened on Nov. 7, 1941, enjoys several historical distinctions, including being the oldest continuously operating casino in Las Vegas by 14 years. Having invented the casino buffet just isn’t one of them.

Look for “Vegas Myths Busted” every Monday on Casino.org. Visit VegasMythsBusted.com to read previously busted Vegas myths. Got a suggestion for a Vegas myth that needs busting? Email corey@casino.org. 

Corey Levitan joined Casino.org in 2022 after a long career covering Las Vegas. He currently covers entertainment, dining and gaming news in Las Vegas.

Corey spent six years covering the Vegas Strip for the Las Vegas Review-Journal, where he also wrote the most popular humor column in the city’s history. (For “Fear and Loafing,” he tried out 176 Vegas jobs, including poker player, blackjack dealer and Follie Bergere dancer.)

Corey has won more than 100 local, state and national awards for his journalism, which has also appeared in Rolling Stone, New York Magazine and the New York Post.

Corey is a New York native whose hobbies include playing guitar, trying to be a better husband, and arguing with strangers on Facebook.

Contact Corey at corey@casino.org.

Comments icon

Conversation (0)

+ Add a comment

Be the first to comment on this article.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.