Expert reviews and ratings of US online casinos

We know that looking through so many reviews can be overwhelming, so each month we pick one of our US editors to highlight their top choice and show you a casino that stands out from the crowd.

1

Expert Rating

4.6/5

BigPirate - my sweeps pick of the month

Trent Rhode

Content Editor35 written reviews

BigPirate is one of the newer sweepstakes casinos I've tested, and it feels far more developed than some of the other recent launches. It has an impressive roster of 1,600+ games from over 20 software providers, and redemptions are also super easy - once you have at least 50 Diamonds, you can redeem them for real prizes. Just be sure to have verified your account and have wagered each Diamond at least once. Once you mix this along with the generous and frequent login bonuses and rotating reward features, BigPirate offers a more polished experience than many new sweepstakes casinos.

Bonus

250,000 GC + 25 Free SC

Pros

• New sweeps casino with unique gameplay
• 3,150+ titles to choose from

Cons

• BigPirate lacks any progressive jackpot slots

Win rate96.49%

Payout time1-3 days

Banking options +4+4

More detailsVisit Site

1481new players thismonth

BigPirate Full Review

Overall rating 4.6/5

Bonuses 4.5/5

Games 4.8/5

Security 4.2/5

Service 4.6/5

Mobile 4.8/5

2

Expert Rating

4.5/5

Caesars - my new real money pick

Trent Rhode

Content Editor35 written reviews

Caesars Palace gave me $10 free just for signing up, which I was able to use on a massive library of 2,000+ games from a wide range of top-tier providers. I really liked that I could play Caesars Palace Originals and Exclusives, along with weekly drop jackpots and newer releases like Temple Tumble 2 and Bad Bass Cash Towers. For me, the variety is what really makes Caesars stand out. There’s Slingo, video poker, and a strong live casino section, which makes it feel like one of the most diverse game selections available in the US. On top of that, ongoing promos like leaderboards, refer-a-friend rewards, and regular bonus spins keep things interesting and added extra value to my gameplay.

Bonus

Get a $10 sign-up bonus + 100% up to $1,000 deposit match + 2,500 Reward Credits

T&Cs Apply

Pros

• High 97.63% RTP and $1 min. withdrawals
• Claim a $10 no deposit bonus

Cons

• High 15x deposit match wagering requirement

Win rate97.65%

Payout time1-2 days

Year established2009

Banking options +5+5

More detailsVisit Site

1115new players thismonth

Caesars Full Review

Overall rating 4.5/5

Bonuses 4.5/5

Games 4.3/5

Security 5/5

Service 4.2/5

Mobile 4.4/5

In our online casino reviews, we look at every area of a casino site to find the best ones. We use a 25-step review process to give the most accurate and trustworthy analysis.

Here is an overview of the different sections you'll see in our reviews, and how our online casino ratings work:

• Casino legitimacy

  Before our analysis begins, we verify that the casino is reputable. We ensure that each site operates legally in the US and has the necessary licensing. Once the brand has passed all our initial checks, we then proceed to our in-depth review process.

  💡Expert insight: Common trust factors we look for when reviewing US casinos include that the games are from reputable providers, that they offer trusted payment methods like Visa and PayPal, and that they hold a relevant license to operate legally within the US.

  
• Bonuses & offers

  Our reviews break down every type of promotion a casino offers, including welcome packages, no deposit bonuses, VIP rewards, rakeback deals, and more. Each is then tested for fairness and value, with wagering, expiry, and contribution rules clearly explained. Our goal is to help you spot the genuine deals and avoid the overhyped ones.

  💡Expert insight: Use our reviews to find what’s important to you. If long-term loyalty rewards matter more than hundreds of spins on sign-up, our bonus sections can guide you to the right casino.

  
• Software & games

  We test every casino’s game selection to see what you’ll actually find once you log in. That means counting the total number of games and slots, checking which providers are available, and seeing how easy the menus and search tools are to use. We also look for exclusive games, progressive jackpots, bonus buys, instant win titles, and live dealer tables, so you know exactly what’s on offer.

  💡Expert insight: We look at how often casinos add new games. So if access to the latest releases is essential to finding a casino you love, look out for this in our reviews.

  
• Withdrawal speed (payments)

  We put each casino’s secure US banking options to the test, from deposit speed to payout reliability. You’ll see which payment methods are supported, how long redemptions take, and whether crypto options are available. We make it clear which sites pay fast and which keep you waiting.

  💡Expert insight: We highlight average payout speeds for every payment method in our reviews. Stick with the fastest options we list to get your winnings as quickly as possible.

  
• Security

  We take casino security seriously. Every site we review is checked for proper licensing, fair play certification, and safe payment systems. We test whether games use RNG software, confirm SSL encryption, and dig into the casino’s terms to see how player funds and data are protected.

  💡Expert insight: Always look for SSL encryption in the site URL (the padlock icon) at any casino you play at. It’s a quick way to confirm your data is secure.

  
• Mobile

  We test every casino's mobile gaming capabilities to see how it performs on both iOS and Android devices. That means checking load speeds, layout, and whether the full game library is available. If there’s an app, we review its features and store ratings, and if not, we test the browser version to make sure it still runs smoothly.

  💡Expert insight: We flag casinos that remove games or limit features on mobile, so if the experience isn't the same as on your computer, you’ll know before joining.

  
• Customer care

  We contact every casino’s support team to see how fast and helpful they are. From live chat and email to social media or phone options, we test every available channel. Our reviews tell you how quickly support responds, how helpful their answers are, and whether they’re available 24/7 or just during business hours.

  💡Expert insight: Our response-time testing helps you spot which casinos reply in seconds versus those that will have you waiting around for answers.

  
• Overall rating

  After testing every key area, we calculate an overall rating out of 5. The score sums up the casino’s real performance, helping you compare sites and choose the one that suits you best.

  💡Expert insight: Our team has 30+ years of experience reviewing and recommending casinos to players, making us one of the most reputable sources for finding online casinos in the USA.

Below is a breakdown of how each of the seven review categories contributes to a casino's overall expert rating on our site. We also factor in research based on user experiences and feedback to cover what matters to online players.

Rating and reviewing casinos is not only about recommending good casinos but also highlighting casinos to avoid. The following three casinos fall into the second category due to suspicious practices that have resulted in players failing to receive winnings.

Expert Rating

1.3/5

Why you should avoid
• Players report not receiving full winnings
• Mentions of misleading bonus terms and payout conditions
• Offshore casino, unlicensed in the US

Expert Rating

1.3/5

Why you should avoid
• 30+ day verification process reported by players
• Withdrawals denied for some users
• Payouts subject to high fees

Expert Rating

1.2/5

Why you should avoid
• Weak responsible gambling process
• No US gambling license
• Reports of winnings wiped from accounts

Find regulated casinos in your state using our localized pages that connect you with all the information you need to know, including the best sites to play online.

Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania officially legalized online gambling in 2017, with its first online casino launching in July 2019. As of today, the state hosts 24 licensed online casino operators, featuring prominent names like BetMGM, FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, Fanatics, and others.

Discover PA online casinos

Michigan

Michigan legalized online casinos in December 2019, with the market officially launching in January 2021. It's one of the largest online gambling markets in the US, featuring 15 licensed operators. Leading platforms include BetMGM, FanDuel, DraftKings, BetRivers, Caesars, and Golden Nugget.

Learn about MI online casinos

New Jersey

New Jersey launched online gambling in 2013 and expanded to legalize Esports betting in 2021. Currently, the state has more than 30 licensed casinos and is widely regarded as a leading example for other states exploring similar legislation. Among the most prominent online casino platforms available in New Jersey are Caesars, DraftKings, BetMGM, and FanDuel.

Read about NJ online casinos

West Virginia

West Virginia became the fifth US state to legalize online gambling in 2019. The state's first online casino, DraftKings, launched in July 2020, followed by additional operators such as BetMGM and BetRivers.

Find out about WV online casinos