New York Court of Appeals to Decide if Daily Fantasy Sports is Gambling
Posted on: October 6, 2021, 06:07h.
Last updated on: October 7, 2021, 10:16h.
The New York Court of Appeals is set to determine whether daily fantasy sports is a game of skill or a game of chance.
Spectrum News 1 reports that the state’s highest court began hearing arguments in Albany on Tuesday. Ultimately, the court will decide once and for all whether the New York State Legislature overstepped its remit when it legalized the contests in 2016.
The 2016 law offered DFS companies a carve-out from state gambling laws. That’s under the premise that they were games of skill. But anti-gambling groups sued, arguing the law was unconstitutional.
Sports Betting Complication
The state’s constitution bans gambling unless an exception can be made via a constitutional amendment, which must be agreed upon by a public referendum.
New York residents voted to legalize sports betting in 2013, for example, at the same time they approved casino gaming. But it was only after the US Supreme Court tossed the federal ban on sports betting that the state’s casinos were permitted to offer these kinds of wagers.
So far, the trial court has ruled that the 2016 law violates the state’s ban on gambling. But it held that the legislature was in its power to decriminalize the contests.
That’s why sites have been able to continue offering DFS in New York pending the resolution of litigation, albeit without oversight from the state. But should the Court of Appeals rule against the state, it would be curtains for the contests in DraftKings’ and FanDuel’s second-biggest DFS market.
Betting on the Bills
On Tuesday, New York Assistant Solicitor General Victor Paladino argued that DFS contains elements of chance, but that skilled players with more knowledge come out on top.
“The contestants have available to them a wealth of information, much like the analytics available to the general managers of the world,” Paladino said during oral arguments, as reported by Spectrum News 1.
You’re arguing that I cannot place a bet on whether the Buffalo Bills win their next game, but I can place a bet on whether or not their lead receiver Stefon Diggs catches the ball ten times or six times,” asked the judge, the Hon. Eugene Fahey.
Since Fahey can legally bet on the Buffalo Bills in New York casinos, it must be assumed he is talking specifically about mobile bets, which are not yet licensed in New York.
Meanwhile, the plaintiffs argued that DFS is gambling, pure and simple.
“I really, frankly, think what the Legislature has done here is bend over backward to find some kind of way to circumvent that,” said the plaintiffs’ attorney Cornelius Murray.
The court typically hands down its decisions six to eight weeks after hearing oral arguments.
Related News Articles
New York Gaming Commission Stops Regulating ‘Illegal’ Daily Fantasy Sports
IRS Could Target Daily Fantasy Sports Winners Under American Rescue Plan
Most Popular
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: The ‘World’s Largest Golden Nugget’ is Real
VEGAS MYTHS BUSTED: Circus Circus is Next on Implosion List
Paris Las Vegas Opens Pedestrian Bridge to Annexed Versailles Tower
Watching the Tropicana Las Vegas Implosion Will be Tricky
Former John Kerry Advisor Arrested After $150M Casino Check Bounced
Most Commented
-
UPDATE: Giant Naked Donald Trump Removed from Side of Las Vegas Freeway
October 1, 2024 — 15 Comments— -
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: Las Vegas is in Imminent Danger of Running Out of Water
September 27, 2024 — 10 Comments— -
Borgata Upgrading Casino as Atlantic City Property Tries to Regain Market Share
September 3, 2024 — 8 Comments— -
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: The Strip Tried Appealing to Families and Failed
August 23, 2024 — 7 Comments—
Last Comments ( 3 )
Thanks for finally talking about > Is Daily Fantasy Sports Gambling? New York Court of Appeals to Decide < Loved it!
How can DFS be illegal gambling when i can bet on sports, slots, table games, or horses. And dont forget about lottery. Why go after just DFS and not slots. Slots are the worst of all. No skill involved at all to push a button but thats not illegal gambling but DFS are.
If you ban DFS, you should ban all betting. Starting with horse racing, then slots and table games. Dont forget about the lottery. It is all gambling. I can walk out my door and be playing slots in 5 minutes. I can drive an hour in any direction and play table games and bet on sports. It makes no sense to me to only go after DFS. That is, by far, the only gambling that has any skill involved. I have been playing slots for 10 years and had 1 signer for 2500$. I have been playing DFS for 10 years and won over 10000 6 times. Ban it all or make it all legal. How you can call DFS illegal gambling and horse racing and slots legal is as stupis as NY Supreme Court for hearing this case.