Toronto Maple Leafs Still a Big Draw for Bettors Despite On-Ice Collapse

Key Points

  • The Maple Leafs continue to attract significant betting action despite a seven-game losing streak
  • Strong recreational betting interest and existing sportsbook liabilities continue to influence Toronto’s futures pricing
  • An expensive offseason overhaul has failed to deliver results, with Toronto’s playoff odds plummeting

The Toronto Maple Leafs may be mired in a seven-game losing streak and sitting last in the National Hockey League (NHL)’s Atlantic Division, but the team continues to attract significant betting action, according to industry observers.

Auston Matthews of the Toronto Maple Leafs brings the puck up ice during a game against the Chicago Blackhawks last night in Chicago. (Image: Melissa Tamez/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

“Certainly, there is a regional bias with the Leafs, even given they’ve never had any success,” said Phill Gray, a sports betting industry consultant and former head of sports betting operations. “People bet with their hearts on ‘national’ teams like this in any sport. Look at the Dallas Cowboys. They still take huge money at any price.

Public Teams Command a Premium

“Leafs are currently 75/1 (+7500) for the Stanley Cup and that’s short in my opinion. I’d be willing to sell them at twice that price. Futures are for the most part like that on ‘public’ teams. Books get a little nervous looking at a huge liability, so the price reflects that when it should be much higher.”

It’s coming up on 60 years since the Leafs last won a Stanley Cup, a remarkable record of futility for a franchise that ranks as the NHL’s wealthiest, valued at US$5.40bn by CNBC.

The organization consistently ranks among the NHL’s biggest payroll spenders. According to PuckPedia, the Leafs sit just US$1.6m below this season’s $104m salary cap.

Expensive Offseason Roster Overhaul

This past summer, after missing the playoffs, the organization underwent a top-to-bottom overhaul, securing the No. 1 overall draft pick and using it to select Gavin McKenna.

The Leafs hired a new general manager in John Chayka and a new head coach in Jim Hiller, brought back franchise icon Mats Sundin and made sweeping changes to their staff.

Then Chayka went to work, overhauling the roster and bringing in 13 new players through trades, free agency, and the draft, including a blockbuster deal with the Columbus Blue Jackets that sent Matthew Knies out the door for Kirill Marchenko. 

Bobrovsky Struggling in Toronto

Among the biggest offseason signings was goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky, who received a three-year, $21m contract. The 38-year-old won back-to-back Stanley Cups with the Florida Panthers in 2024 and 2025 and is a likely future Hall of Famer.

It’s been a decidedly different story in Toronto. Bobrovsky is 3-9-2 with a 3.65 goals-against average and an .874 save percentage. His struggles have been among the biggest reasons for the Leafs’ collapse.

Marchenko impressed with six goals and 14 points in 14 games before injuring his knee. He has reportedly resumed practicing, although the team has yet to provide a timeline for his return. 

The Leafs, 8-13-2, are 1-8-0 since Marchenko got hurt in Calgary against the Flames on Oct. 26.

Leafs Nearing Rock Bottom

Now, after getting beaten up in Chicago last night, 6-3, by the 31st-overall Blackhawks, Hiller used the word “disappointing” in Sportsnet reporting to sum up his team’s play. Bobrovsky was in net for all six goals.

“We win as a team; we lose as a team,” he said. “I know we talk a lot about the goaltender, but there are plenty of people that are part of this, including the coaches.”

Media commentators today said both Hiller and Bobrovsky have been clear misses for Chayka. Rock bottom? Over the losing streak, the team has averaged 1.71 goals per game. Goal differential is -17, power-play percentage is 7.7%, penalty killing is 58.8%, and save percentage is .865. Those numbers have buried them in a hole in the standings that may already have doomed their playoff aspirations.

Bettor Loyalty Remains Strong

The local market is ornery again, with a negative media drumbeat and calls for Hiller’s firing and trades involving prominent players such as William Nylander, who holds a full no-trade clause. 

The challenge is that the Leafs have little salary-cap flexibility to address glaring roster deficiencies, particularly on defense, and a limited pool of young players and draft picks to use as trade capital. 

Against that backdrop, one of the more fascinating dynamics in the Canadian sports betting market is the apparent disconnect between the Leafs’ on-ice performance and their enduring appeal among bettors.

Stanley Cup Odds Drift

“The Leafs are going through a tough stretch, but the loyalty of their fan base hasn’t wavered,” said Adam Landeka, vice-president of sportsbook, theScore Bet. 

“We’re still seeing strong engagement on Leafs games among Canadian bettors, with only a modest decline in activity despite the team’s struggles. There has been a slight shift toward betting against Toronto, but that’s largely a reflection of recent results rather than any significant sharp betting activity.”

The biggest story, he added, has been around how dramatically the team’s outlook has changed. The Leafs opened the season at 30/1 (+3000) to win the Cup and have drifted to 75/1 (+7500) at the Score Bet. Their playoff odds have taken an even bigger hit, moving from -105 to +475.

“We’ve also seen significant early-season interest in Leafs futures, which continues to influence where those prices sit today,” said Landeka.

For all the Leafs’ shortcomings on the ice, the enduring power of the franchise is still evident at sportsbooks.

Mark is a long-time, seasoned journalist, as a writer and editor, working for several Toronto daily newspapers, then moving over to the digital arena, covering both sports and business. Over the past few years he moved over to the gaming arena, specifically covering the igaming industry in Canada for several platforms, as well as writing on sports betting.

Comments icon

Conversation (0)

+ Add a comment

Be the first to comment on this article.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.