NFL Insider Jason La Canfora: Cowboys Could Replace Brian Schottenheimer if They Miss Playoffs

Key Points

  • Jason La Canfora reports a growing expectation around the NFL that Dallas could have a new head coach and staff in 2027 if it misses the playoffs.
  • Jerry Jones’ response to the Cowboys’ defensive struggles suggests he could evaluate the entire coaching staff in January, La Canfora writes.
  • A longtime personnel executive who knows Jones believes he will have a hard time bringing the current coaching staff back.

The Dallas Cowboys are still alive in the lowly NFC East, even after nearly giving up 50 points at home to the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday (Nov. 15), wasting a 40-point performance of their own.

That’s the “good news” as it were.

Cowboys Jerry Jones sports betting Texas
Jerry Jones, owner of the Dallas Cowboys, looks on before a game between the Philadelphia Eagles and the Dallas Cowboys at Lincoln Financial Field on Oct. 26, 2026 (Image: Getty)

As to everything else going on around the football team, well, big problems are ahead. Owner Jerry Jones seems to understand that the die is cast for this 2026 season and, particularly, for his 2026 defense. He failed to add another big-money defensive player at last week’s trade deadline even after mulling it for a week.

He’s already added former National Football League (NFL) head coach Mike Pettine to the defensive staff to help bolster rookie defensive coordinator Christian Parker, and he’s already heard the ringing cheers and applause for visiting teams who come to Arlington, Texas, loaded with fan support to put up gaudy offensive numbers at the Cowboys’ expense.

Jones and Schottenheimer Respond to Defensive Struggles

To those who have watched Jones closely over the years and listened even more closely, the dichotomy between how he spoke about Dallas’ defensive woes after Sunday’s (Nov 15.) demoralizing loss and the way embattled head coach Brian Schottenheimer spoke about it was telling.

“We tackled like shit in the second half,” Schottenheimer said, railing against the repeated critical mistakes that allowed Deebo Samuel and Christian McCaffrey to execute explosive touchdown after explosive touchdown.

Jones, however, was far more pragmatic about the debacle – alas, he is the one most responsible for plucking Parker from the Eagles and anointing the young coach as the one to fix his perpetually failed defense in the first place.

“This is what it is” Jones explained. “He’s a young coach who is in his first year coordinating … I’ll weigh his early times. But I’ve been with teams that had some good coordinators on defense that ended up winning Super Bowls.”

Cowboys Defense Leaves Coaching Staff Under Pressure

So what does it mean?

Dallas is allowing 394 yards per game, the worst in the NFL, and 5.2 yards per rush, the worst in the NFL (that’s been a chronic problem for years; getting destroyed on early downs has opened up the pass game for opponents and kept them remarkably balanced).

The Cowboys have allowed the third-most points in the NFL, at over 28 per game.

But it’s also nearly Thanksgiving, and they have a short week ahead with less time to prepare for the Thursday (Nov. 19) game. They just made the move for Pettine weeks ago (“Jerry hired the wrong guy; he should have hired Wink,” one longtime NFL personnel man said of longtime NFL defensive coordinator Wink Martindale).

Pettine’s impact has been negligible at best, while right in the NFC East, Washington’s hiring of former head coach Steve Wilks to right its defense has proven far more beneficial.

The fact that Jones didn’t sink more draft assets into this defense through trades read to some in the league like this defense was too broken for Josh Sweat or Khalil Mack to save it.

“The fact he didn’t do anything has to be bad news for Schotty,” one GM told me after the deadline, surprised Jones didn’t make another move.

Missing Playoffs Could Bring Coaching Changes in 2027

Indeed, Jones seems to be implying that rather than throw a young coordinator aside this late in the season, he’s going to evaluate the entire coaching staff together come January and mull sweeping changes.

The bar has been set so low in the division with the Eagles collapsing that if Dallas cannot reach the postseason, then there is a mounting expectation in the NFL that there will be a new coach there in 2027, and a new staff.

They play the lowly Titans, then host the Eagles on Thanksgiving and have a bye looming in Week 14.

Numerous execs have suggested to me through the course of the season that the fact Cowboys fans are not really buying this coaching staff – with criticisms about Jones being unwilling to pay for top coaches coming from all corridors – will have as big an impact on Jones as anything else, with marketing and branding his specialty since before he bought the team.

“He’s going to have a hard time bringing this group back, and he knows it,” one longtime personnel executive who has known Jones for decades and generally had a pulse on his feelings told me. “It’s not working.”

Despite it all, the Giants have just one more win than Dallas – their saving grace right now. And Dallas has three divisional games still to play, so another panic move seems unlikely now. In January, however, expect plenty.

Jason La Canfora has covered the NFL full-time since 2004. He covered the Washington Commanders for five years at The Washington Post, then spent three years as NFL insider for the NFL network across all platforms and 10 years as the NFL insider for CBS Sports, appearing every Sunday on 'The NFL today'. before returning to The Washington Post to cover the NFL for 5 years.

He has deep connections in front offices, with coaches and agents across the league to bring unique perspective to his coverage, along with an understanding of advanced data.

Comments icon

Conversation (0)

+ Add a comment

Be the first to comment on this article.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.