Sexiest Man Alive Odds & Predictions: The Favorite Heartthrobs

With a resolution date of late October, Polymarket continues to receive significant interest in the People’s Sexiest Man Alive market. 

This allows you to buy and sell shares on which hunk will follow in the footsteps of Patrick Dempsey, John Krasinski, and Jonathan Bailey to win the magazine’s prestigious award. 

Volume has already surpassed $124,600, with the frontrunners comprising the usual suspects of international artists, Hollywood stars, and top athletes. The market has experienced a surge recently, with Noah Wyle now emerging as the overwhelming favorite after winning Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series awards at both the Emmys and the Golden Globes.

Wyle now has a 78% win probability on Polymarket. But is the smart money on the current favorite or an outsider? Let’s take a closer look at the initial market movements and best value picks in 2026.

Looking to make a trade on the Sexiest Man Alive market? Use our exclusive Polymarket bonus code to earn a $20 trading bonus when you register and deposit $10. If you want more options outside of Polymarket, read our guide on the best places for entertainment betting.

Where Has Money Been Spent So Far?

The list of candidates for the People’s Sexiest Man Alive features eight handsome celebrities. Bad Bunny was the initial frontrunner after his controversial appearance at Super Bowl LX. This caused his win probability to peak at 34% on July 29th.

However, his odds have since contracted to just 2% amid Wyle’s surge. Although he remains prominent in the global news cycle with his major apparel launches and enduring pop culture legacy, his price has almost certainly peaked earlier in the year and has minimal upside.

He may not have the same profile, but Connor Storrie’s stock has risen immensely since appearing as a breakout star of the romantic drama “Heated Rivalry”. His co-star Hudson Williams is also a contender, creating a scenario where selectors may be split between the pair.

Michael B. Jordan and Timothée Chalamet are also among the remaining contenders. Remember, the previous six award winners have also been categorized as being on-screen talent. 

Noah Wyle Odds – A Sudden Contender, But is He Overpriced?

“Noah Wyle” | “Yes” at 79¢ | 78% Chance

Wyle only entered this market on October 7th, less than a month after his “Best Actor” award at the Emmys. His hit show “The Pitt” won a total of six awards, driving an unexpected career rival and sending Wyle’s “Yes” price in this particular market soaring to 79¢. Such momentum can be pivotal in sentiment-based markets.

There’s also historical precedent for Wyle’s surge to victory. Both Patrick Dempsey (2023) and George Clooney (1997) won the award after spending years starring in hit medical dramas. Dempsey was also 57 when he won the award three years ago, and Wyle may find himself on a similar trajectory at the age of 55.

Narratives aside, however, Wyle’s advancing age does make him something of an outlier as a potential winner. The average age of a People Magazine Sexiest Man Alive winner is 38.9 years old, and Wyle would have to buck this historic trend to win the award.

Momentum is also a consideration here, and Wyle’s “Yes” price may have peaked too early. We’re still at least two weeks from the winner being confirmed, while Wyle’s Emmys success was achieved in early September.

Given the timeframe and the fact that Wyle’s price has minimal upside prior to settlement, backing the actor now is essentially a straight bet on him winning the award. This type of trade should be avoided in this market, so I’d recommended seeking out alternative picks.

Michael B. Jordan Markets – An Underpriced Contender With Huge Upside

“Michael B. Jordan” | “Yes” at 2.9¢ | 2% Chance

Not only do Hollywood’s leading men have a huge profile advantage over most contenders, but People Magazine’s late-October award selection window coincides with a high volume of autumn movie releases and speculation ahead of the upcoming Oscars.

This is why Michael B. Jordan offers such excellent value. The 2020 award winner has both directed and starred in the highly-anticipated “Thomas Crown Affair”, which is a high-budget romantic heist thriller that co-stars Adria Arjona.

This is slated for release on March 5th, 2027, which means that Jordan’s press tour and media appearances will gather momentum just as People Magazine’s selection committee starts its formal deliberations.

Remember, Jordan is also established as one of Hollywood’s biggest names, with his starring roles in Creed and Black Panther affording him a huge global following. 

Jordan’s pricing has been incredibly volatile during the previous three weeks, rising from 14.6¢ to 27.7¢ before falling back to its current benchmark of just 2.9¢. However, People will announce the winners of the individual Readers’ Choice categories on October 20th. Although this has no bearing on the final selection, success for Jordan here could drive sentiment and send his “Yes” price soaring again.

This may create the opportunity to sell and lock in a profit prior to the market settling. Sure, this increases the risk of you being caught in a liquidity trap, but the latest insider information seems to be suggesting that Jordan’s odds of winning are higher than his current price implies.

Connor Storrie Odds – A Young Contender With Significant Upside

“Connor Storrie” | “Yes” at 0.9¢ | 1% Chance

Heated Rivalry is established as Crave’s most-watched original series to date, with the chemistry between co-stars Hudson Williams and Connor Storrie central to the drama’s sustained commercial success.

Storrie received an Emmy nomination following his star turn, ensuring that both his profile and his stock remain high. However, while his win probability has remained relatively consistent between 9% and 14% since June 1st, Wyle’s surge has helped to send it plummeting to just 1%.

There are also several obstacles to trading “Yes” on Storrie. Firstly, Storrie is just 26 years old, and considerably younger than the age of the average award winner. Storrie’s co-star Hudson Williams is also in contention, so selectors may be split between the two during the deliberation window.

These factors cast doubt on Storrie’s odds of winning the award. However, the actor’s “Yes” price is now significantly discounted at just 0.9¢, while he could also benefit from speculation after the individual Readers’ Choice winners are announced.

So, you could buy “Yes” shares now and hold your position until October 20th at least. This could unlock a potential upside and opportunities to sell, liquidity permitting. Just note that this is a high-risk pick that should be approached with caution.

Timothée Chalamet Odds – An Underpriced Underdog

“Timothée Chalamet” | “Yes” at 4.2¢ | 3% Chance

Last but not least, we come to actor Timothée Chalamet. The 30-year-old has seen his price fluctuate wildly in the last six weeks, rising from just 0.8¢ on August 13th to 10.8¢ before contracting back to the current benchmark of 4.2¢. But does he offer value at this price?

Chalamet certainly ticks a number of boxes as a potential Sexiest Man Alive award winner. Since April 2023, for example, he has been in a relationship with socialite and entrepreneur Kylie Jenner, increasing his total social media following by more than 3.2 million.

What’s more, the French-American actor will be involved in two film releases in the coming months. “Dune: Part Three” is slated to be released on December 18, 2026, so he’ll be conducting his own media tour throughout the fall. 

He’ll also star alongside Selena Gomez in the romance science fiction comedy “Not Alone”, with this film set to make its Box Office debut on April 16th, 2027.

Polymarket currently gives Chalamet a 3% win probability, while his current price of just 4.2¢ offers obvious value. It’s also up by 425.00% in a little over two months. Buying “Yes” shares now at this price also unlocks a huge possible upside, especially when you consider the actor’s high profile and potential for visibility on the national chat show circuit. 

The Last Word – How Will the Market Be Resolved?

Whether you’re backing the emotional pull of Noah Wyle, Michael B. Jordan’s Hollywood smile, or Timothée Chalamet to finally make the cover, it’s important to understand how Polymarket resolves the market.  

It is based on the person named by People Magazine as the Sexiest Man Alive. Settlement is expected by later October, with the Readers’ Choice Poll results set to be unveiled next week. Be sure to remember this when looking to sell while avoiding low-liquidity traps.

While it has never happened before, the market will resolve to “Other” should People shock us all by announcing multiple winners. So, strap in and keep a close eye on odds changes for this dashing market at Polymarket. 

Since it’s hard to accurately predict a winner in this market, a better strategy is to buy underpriced outcomes and flip them for a profit. This requires you to set a viable exit strategy, which helps you to lock in an early profit. This can also enable you to minimize potential losses.

Want to make any of these trades? Use our exclusive CORG promo code on Polymarket to earn a $20 trading bonus when you register and deposit $10.