New York Sports Betting Handle Hits September Record $2.4B Despite Prediction Market Rise

Key Points

  • New York sports betting handle rose 5% year over year to more than $2.4 billion in September
  • Year-to-date handle increased 3.7%, but sportsbook revenue fell 5.8% to $1.1 billion as operators’ hold dropped
  • New York’s growth contrasts with New Jersey’s 4.1% handle decline, offering a counterpoint to industry claims that prediction markets are hurting sportsbooks

New York sports betting handle continues to grow despite claims from the regulated gambling industry that sports prediction markets are siphoning away business.

New York sports betting handle
A billboard at Madison Square Garden features actor Jamie Foxx promoting the BetMGM Sportsbook. Sports betting handle in New York continues to expand, despite concerns about prediction markets stealing play. (Image: Shutterstock)

The New York State Gaming Commission reports that sports bettors wagered more than $2.4 billion in September. That represents a 5% increase over September 2025—an uptick of nearly $114 million in handle.

Through September, overall 2026 sports betting volume is up 3.7% year over year, with players placing roughly $697 million more in wagers than during the same period in 2025.

Growth is even more pronounced across the state’s 2026–27 fiscal year. Over the first six months beginning in April, sports betting handle reached nearly $12.6 billion—a 6.9% increase compared to the same stretch in 2025.

That surge in volume, however, has not yielded higher top-line profits for operators. Because bettors fared better over the past six months, sportsbook gross revenues fell 5.8% to $1.1 billion as average win percentage (hold) dropped from 10% to 8.8%.

Are Prediction Markets Hurting Sportsbooks?

Representatives of the legal gaming sector maintain that sports trading on federally regulated prediction markets encroaches on state-regulated sportsbooks, diverting volume from the nine platforms featured in New York revenue reports.

Prediction market platforms push back against that framing, arguing that users are trading against other participants rather than wagering against a traditional house.

Regardless of which legal interpretation prevails, the American Gaming Association (AGA) argues that prediction platforms cost states substantial tax revenue. 

Prediction market platforms are offering illegal sports betting nationwide outside the state and tribal regulatory frameworks that protect consumers. They override voter decisions, bypass key consumer protections, ignore state and tribal laws, and avoid licensing and taxes,” the AGA said.

A running ticker on the group’s website shows projected lost state gaming tax revenue nearing $1.6 billion “since prediction markets began offering back-door sports betting” in late 2025.

The AGA says that means states have less money to allocate to schools, hospitals, infrastructure, and other local funding initiatives.

“Prediction markets contribute nothing,” the AGA said.

National Handle Trends

New York is the largest sports betting state among the 39 states that have legal sports gambling. The state is home to Bally Bet, BetMGM, BetRivers, Caesars Sportsbook, DraftKings, theScore, Fanatics, FanDuel, and Resorts World Bet.

New York’s sports betting handle continuing to grow even as prediction markets increase trading volume offers a counterpoint for market proponents.

In Illinois, the second-largest sports betting state, online handle on professional and college sports through August 2026 totaled $9.3 billion. That marked a 5.7% increase from 2025, when bets totaled $8.8 billion.  

However, not every sports betting state is seeing higher handle in 2026. In New Jersey, sports betting handle is down 4.1% through September, with bets declining from $8.6 billion to $8.3 billion.

Devin O'Connor
Devin O'Connor Senior Reporter

Devin O'Connor is a senior reporter for Casino.org, covering politics, casino business, and gaming news.

Devin came on board with Casino.org in 2014. He lives in Arlington, Va.

Comments icon

Conversation (0)

+ Add a comment

Be the first to comment on this article.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.