Judge Tosses Case Questioning Texas Tribe’s Sovereign Immunity Due to ‘Illegal Gaming’
Posted on: July 1, 2020, 06:37h.
Last updated on: July 1, 2020, 09:51h.
A Houston man who was injured at a tribal bingo hall in East Texas last year argued in a federal lawsuit that the Alabama-Coushatta tribe should be liable for damages because its “illegal gaming” activities undermined its sovereign immunity.
![Alabama-Coushatta Lawsuit Sovereign Immunity](https://www.casino.org/news/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/naskila.jpg)
But the argument was rejected by the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas this week and the case dismissed.
Plaintiff Burrel Jones visited the Naskila Gaming center in October 2019 on the Alabama-Coushatta’s reservation in Livingston, Texas. On the way out, he slipped on a staircase, fracturing his humerus and sustaining radial nerve damage, both of which required surgery.
He also lost consciousness during the fall, resulting in impaired cognition and communication, impaired functional mobility and ADLs, impaired safety awareness, impulsivity, nausea, emesis and left medial leg pruritus, according to the lawsuit.
Immune Response
Federal and tribal governments generally enjoy immunity from lawsuits unless they specifically choose to waive this immunity. The Alabama Coushatta’s status as a federally recognized tribe means it enjoys sovereign immunity as a tribal nation.
But Jones argued that the tribe had abrogated its immunity and tribal status by “repeated violations” of the Texas Restoration Act, the legislation that re-established the relationship between the Alabama-Coushatta and the federal government and restored the tribe its land.
The act stipulated that the tribe is prohibited from offering any type of gambling that is not available elsewhere in the state.
This has been a bone of contention between the tribe and the state for some time. The Alabama-Coushatta argue that the class II electronic gaming machines on offer at Naskila Gaming are consistent with the charitable bingo games available across Texas.
The state’s attorney general, Ken Paxton, begs to differ. He wants to close down Naskila Gaming and is demanding a $10,000 penalty for every day the facility has been open since May 2016.
The matter is the subject of ongoing litigation. But a bill currently in Congress, sponsored by US Rep Brian Babin (R-Texas), seeks to have the anti-gaming clause wiped out.
Common-Law Right
Lawyers for the tribe argued that since the state and the tribe are already engaged in litigation, any declaration on the legality of gaming in a separate case would be “particularly inappropriate.”
Moreover, even if the tribe were in violation of the Restoration Act, this would not waive its immunity, lawyers said, and the plaintiff’s lawsuit did not demonstrate how it could.
“Tribal immunity is a common-law right of the Tribe that exists independent of the Restoration Act, subject to express modification by Congress or the Tribe itself (which does not exist here),” argued the tribes’ lawyers in a motion to dismiss.
“No violation of the Restoration Act could even conceivably give rise to judicial revocation of the Tribe’s centuries-old sovereign authority,” they added.
The judge agreed that only Congress could repudiate the doctrine of sovereign immunity and not the courts, which meant the case had no standing.
Related News Articles
Most Popular
LOST VEGAS: The Foster Brooks Robot at MGM Grand
Bally’s Sets Date for Tropicana Las Vegas Implosion & Party
Most Commented
-
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: You Don’t Have to Pay Resort Fees
August 2, 2024 — 16 Comments— -
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: Elvis Was a Straight-Up Racist
August 9, 2024 — 11 Comments— -
ANTI-SOCIAL BEHAVIOR: Vegas Casino Buffet Stunt in Poor Taste Goes Viral
August 16, 2024 — 7 Comments— -
VEGAS MYTHS RE-BUSTED: The Strip Tried Appealing to Families and Failed
August 23, 2024 — 7 Comments—
Last Comments ( 3 )
Machines are definitely rigged. It’s impossible to win anything and sadly it wasn’t just me, next to me person put $2k and won only $7. The owner off casino should go to jail for robbing customers. There should be rules and regulations every casino should follow. They loosen and tight slot machines as they wish.
After ⅼooking over a handful of the articleѕ on your site, I seriously appreciate your waʏ of blogging. I book mɑrked іt to my bookmarҝ site list and will be checking back in the neaг future. Please ϲheck out my website as well and tell me how yоu feеl.
If Burrel Jones was so concerned about this being an illegal place to be then why was he there doing something illegal? Wouldn't that be a case of"Dirty Hands"? We need outlets right now.... and I venture to say that we are more than willing to be extra careful in our surroundings.