The Fear Factor: How Fear Sabotages Poker Play (and How to Play Fearlessly)

Overcoming Fear in Poker: What You’ll Learn

• Identify and Confront Fear in Poker: Gain insights into recognizing the specific instances where fear influences your poker decisions and learn to approach these situations with increased awareness and confidence.

• Utilize Exposure Training: Discover how gradually exposing yourself to uncomfortable poker scenarios can help build fear tolerance and improve your decision-making skills over time.

• Effective Reflection Techniques: Learn practical methods for analyzing past games to understand fear-based decisions and strategize improved responses for future sessions.

• Expand Comfort Zones Safely: Understand how to push your limits by playing with slightly higher stakes or tougher opponents, thereby enhancing your skill set without unnecessary risk.

• Develop Courage in Poker: Embrace courage as a learned skill, equipping yourself to manage fear’s presence in the game and focusing on trusting your processes to consistently make strong plays.

You’re deep in a poker tournament, and the blinds are going up. You’re dealt A♠️J♠️ on the button.
The cutoff opens, and you know this is a perfect 3-bet spot.

But something holds you back. Your finger hovers over the raise button… and instead, you just call. The flop misses you completely, and you get check-raised. You fold, frustrated—not at the board, but at yourself, and think, “Why didn’t I just pull the trigger preflop?”

Fear doesn’t always scream. Sometimes it whispers through hesitation, overthinking, or playing it safe. It convinces you that folding is better than risking looking stupid. That checking is smarter than getting it wrong. That now isn’t the time.

But here’s the harsh reality:

Fear doesn’t protect your stack sizes—it limits your long-term success

Image Credit: VGstockstudio/Shutterstock

If you’ve ever missed a bluff, avoided tough situations. or second-guessed rational decisions you knew was right, you’re not alone.

This article will show you how fear in poker creeps into your game and, more importantly, how to play with courage, even when you feel that poker anxiety rising.

Let me give you an example. Matt was deep in a live $1K MTT, and he had a healthy stack and was seated at a soft poker table with two short stacks on his left.

The action folded to him on the cutoff. He looked down at 9♣️8♣️. He knew this was a clear open from his study sessions, especially with ICM pressure on the blinds.

But Matt just… sat there. His hands got a little shaky. His mind flooded with doubt.

“What if I get 3-bet?”
 “What if I bust now and look like an idiot?”
 “I should just wait for a better spot…”

So he mucked.

After the event, he told me:

“I knew what the right play was. I just couldn’t do it because I didn’t want to screw up.”

That’s how fear works. It doesn’t always feel like sheer panic. Instead, it often shows up as a quiet, creeping reluctance. And if you don’t have the tools to recognize and work through it, fear will talk you out of your edge.

What Fear Looks Like at the Table

Fear isn’t always dramatic. It doesn’t have to feel like panic or cause you to sweat through your hoodie.

In a poker game, fear tends to show up in far more subtle (and sneaky) ways. Most poker players don’t even realize it’s fear because they just think they’re being “careful,” “disciplined,” or “waiting for a better spot.”

But if you look closely, you’ll start to notice the patterns.

Common Signs You’re Playing from Fear:

• You don’t pull the trigger on a bluff even though your read is clear.
  
• You flat instead of 3-bet because you’re worried they’ll 4-bet and “put you in a spot.”
  
• You fold strong hands that are part of your opening range because it’s close to the bubble.
  
• You avoid marginal but profitable calls in big pots because you don’t want to look foolish.
  
• You pass on thin value bets to “avoid variance” when you’re deep in a tournament.
  
• You check behind when you should bet by telling yourself, “cautious is smart,” even when the math disagrees.
  

Why Fear Is So Sneaky (and So Powerful)

Poker fears aren’t just an emotion. It’s a biological alarm system that’s designed to protect you from danger. And in life, that’s incredibly helpful. During an major poker tournament? Not so much.

Here’s What Happens When Fear Kicks In:

Your brain interprets uncertainty and pressure as a threat. That triggers your amygdala, which is the part of the brain responsible for fight, flight, or freeze. This response floods your body with adrenaline and cortisol.

And what does that do?

It narrows your focus, dampens your creative thinking, and shuts down long-term reasoning to lock you into short-term safety mode.

In other words, your brain is literally trying to protect you from risk, right when you need to be able to take calculated risks the most.

Image Credit: Studio Romantic/Shutterstock

Why Fear in Poker Hurts Your Game

In poker, every hand requires making decisions with incomplete information.

So when fear tells you:

• “Wait for a safer spot…”
  
• “You might regret this…”
  
• “Don’t embarrass yourself…”
  

…it’s convincing you to play small, play safe, and avoid discomfort. But the best (and most profitable) poker decisions are often uncomfortable. Fear doesn’t always stop you from acting, but it frequently ensures that your actions are smaller than they should be.

That’s why it’s so sneaky. It makes you think you’re being smart when you’re protecting yourself from imagined failure in poker.

How Fear Sabotages Your Game

Fear doesn’t just change how you feel; it changes how you play.

You may not even notice it at first. But over time, fear-based decisions quietly eat away at your edge, confidence, and win-rate.

Here’s how fear shows up at the table—and what it costs you.

Inaction: The Bluff You Never Made

You’ve studied the spot. You know the board favors your range.

But you check back, telling yourself something like, “Maybe now’s not the time.”
 “It’s probably close anyway.” “Let’s just keep it simple.”

What happened? Fear disguised itself as logic. And just like that, the opportunity was gone.

Overcorrection: The Spew That Follows the Fear

After playing scared and missing spots, fear can swing the other way:

“I’m done playing like a nit. I’m taking my spots now.”

Now you’re overcorrecting by making emotionally fueled hero calls, ill-timed bluffs, or loose opens just to prove you’re not afraid.

But you’re still playing from fear, just in the opposite direction.

Image Management: Playing to Look Good, Not to Win

You pass on a profitable line because you’re worried about what your tablemates, stream viewers, or study group will think if it goes wrong.

You’re no longer making +EV decisions but playing to protect your ego.

Fear has shifted your goal from execution to reputation.

Paralysis: Thinking Yourself Out of Good Plays

You start tanking in spots you’ve played a hundred times. You second-guess every line and feel stuck between “what’s right” and “what’s safe.”

This is fear wearing a GTO poker hoodie.

You’re not analyzing better—you’re just stalling because fear has sapped your confidence.

One of the Worst Forms of Fear?

Knowing what the right play is… and not making it. Not because you’re lazy or unskilled. But because you were afraid of being wrong, of losing chips, of looking foolish.

That’s not a solid strategy. That’s fear dictating your playing style.

The Mindset Shift: From Fearful to Fearless

Let’s get one thing clear: Being fearless doesn’t mean you don’t feel fear. It means you don’t let fear make your decisions.

Fear is going to show up. Especially when:

• You’re deep in a tournament
  
• You’re facing a big river shove
  
• You’re playing high stakes
  
• You’re about to make a bold move

That doesn’t make you weak. It makes you normal.

The difference between average players and elite players isn’t whether they feel fear. It’s how they respond to it.

Your New Mental Cue:

Practice telling yourself, “I can feel fear… and still choose the right play.”

It doesn’t matter if your heart’s racing or your stomach drops. You can still breathe, ground yourself, and take the action that aligns with your strategy. That’s what poker courage looks like.

Redefine Fearlessness:

It’s not:

• Playing recklessly
  
• Ignoring emotion
  
• Faking confidence
  

It is:

• Feeling uncomfortable and acting anyway
  
• Trusting your process more than your fear
  
• Prioritizing long-term growth over short-term comfort
  

You don’t become fearless by getting rid of fear. You become fearless by building the capacity to act in spite of it. And the more you practice that, the stronger and more consistent your game becomes.

Tools to Play Fearlessly (Even When You’re Scared)

You can’t always stop fear from showing up. But you can train yourself to play with clarity and confidence even when fear is whispering in your ear.

Here are four high-performance tools that help you do just that:

Pre-Session Mental Rehearsal

Before your session, spend 2–3 minutes visualizing the spots that typically scare you:

• The big bluff you’ve been avoiding
  
• The bubble ICM spot where you tighten up too much
  
• The 3-bet bluff you keep passing on
  

Now picture yourself handling it with calm confidence:

• You breathe.
  
• You think clearly.
  
• You execute.
  

Mental rehearsal builds familiarity, and familiar situations are less scary.

Use the “If I Weren’t Scared…” Prompt

This quick mindset cue cuts straight to the heart of fear-based avoidance. Ask yourself, “If I weren’t scared right now, what would I do?”

Then follow up with: “What would the best version of me do here, even if it doesn’t work out?”

This is a great way to reconnect with your values and your A-game process.

Post-Hand Reflection: Strategy or Fear?

After a hand that felt intense or uncertain, ask: “Did I check, fold, or otherwise pass on a spot because it was strategically sound or because I was afraid?”

No judgment, just observation. Over time, this builds self-awareness, and awareness builds confidence.

Title Image Credit: Bordovski Yauheni/Shutterstock

Create a Courage Log

Start a simple list in your journal, app, or notebook.

Each time you:

• Pull the trigger on a tough bluff
  
• Make a correct call even if it stings
  
• Play through fear with intention
  

…log it.

These moments prove that you’re the kind of player who doesn’t let fear win.

And on the days when doubt creeps back in, that courage log will remind you that you can play fearlessly.

Training Fear Tolerance Off the Felt

If you only work on your mental game during sessions, you’ll always be playing catch-up.

Fear tolerance, just like your technical skills, can be developed between sessions through intentional discomfort and reflection.

The only way to get more comfortable with fear is to spend time with it. Not all at once. Not recklessly. But progressively.

This is what psychologists call exposure training, and you can apply it directly to online poker.

Here’s How to Train Fear Tolerance Off the Felt:

Review Hands You Avoided

Pull up past spots where fear made you fold, skip, or stall. Ask:

• “What was I afraid of here?”
  
• “What would I do next time if I felt 10% more confident?”
  
• “How could I prepare for this spot better in advance?”
  

Practice Sharing Hands Publicly

Many players avoid posting hands because they fear judgment or being told they played it wrong. Start doing it anyway so you can get feedback. Stay curious and build up some emotional calluses.

Play Slightly Outside Your Comfort Zone

Try:

• One step up in stakes (with a clear stop-loss)
  
• Playing tougher lineups
  
• Leaning into discomfort in your study group or coaching
  

This isn’t about recklessness—it’s about expanding your capacity.

Reflect After Fear-Based Spots

After a session, write down:

• “When did fear show up today?”
  
• “How did I respond?”
  
• “What can I do next time to respond better?”

That reflection is the training. Remember, you don’t rise to the level of your motivation.
You fall to the level of your preparation. And players who prepare for fear by expecting it, welcoming it, and rehearsing how they’ll respond develop a quiet, almost unshakable confidence.

Final Thought: Courage Is a Skill

Fear in poker will always be part of your poker journey. There’s too much uncertainty, pressure, and risk for it not to be. But your goal isn’t to eliminate fear. It’s to stop letting it control your game.

You don’t need to feel 100% confident to make a great play. You just need to trust your process more than your fear.

Title Image Credit: LightField Studios/Shutterstock