Atlantic City Casino Report Highlights Brick-and-Mortar Concerns Amid NYC Threat

Posted on: May 11, 2025, 11:37h. 

Last updated on: May 11, 2025, 01:01h.

  • Atlantic City casinos will face new competition in the coming years by way of New York City
  • In-person play in Atlantic City has remained relatively flat in recent years
  • Atlantic City continues to provide many economic benefits in South Jersey

All nine casinos in Atlantic City were profitable last year, but a newly published report sheds light on growing concerns about the resorts’ ability to compete long-term once multibillion-dollar gaming properties open in nearby New York City.

Atlantic City casino industry gaming revenue
The Atlantic City Boardwalk is seen on Nov. 7, 2023. A new report highlights the many benefits the Atlantic City casino industry delivers to the regional economy, but raises concerns about brick-and-mortar revenue. (Image: Shutterstock)

For a second consecutive year, Stockton University’s Lloyd D. Levenson Institute of Gaming, Hospitality, and Tourism, or LIGHT, released a study, “Impact: Atlantic City Casino Industry.” The annual publication analyzes the economic contributions of the Atlantic City gaming sector and “illustrates the importance of all stakeholders working together to ensure its continued success,” explained LIGHT Faculty Director Jane Bokunewicz.

The 2024 “Impact” details that while overall gross gaming revenue (GGR) climbed 9% from 2023, land-based win contracted by more than 1%. Aside from increased online sports betting and internet casino gaming, brick-and-mortar GGR has not returned to pre-pandemic levels despite continued reinvestments by the nine casinos. 

Revenue Not Keeping Up With Costs 

With the casinos directing much of their online sports and iGaming money to their third-party partners like FanDuel and DraftKings, net revenues fell 0.5% in 2024 to $3.31 billion.

The ‘flat’ trajectory of traditional, brick-and-mortar casino revenues has become concerning to some, especially considering recent, substantial investments Atlantic City properties have made to enhance [the] in-person integrated casino resort experience,” Bokunewicz wrote. “Given inflation and other continuing market pressures, this performance was not enough to offset operators’ expenses.”

LIGHT, utilizing vehicle counts at the Pleasantville Toll Plaza along the Atlantic City Expressway, estimated that the East Coast casino capital welcomed approximately 18 million people in 2024. While that was a slight increase on 2023, it remained about two million fewer visitors than in 2019, and six million fewer visitors than in 2009.

Because of higher costs, the nine casinos managed to charge about $1.6 million more for food and beverage and $109.1 million more for hotel rooms than they did in 2019. However, due to lingering inflation from the pandemic, paired with higher wages and benefits costs, much of that added revenue went to cover increased overhead.

Nonetheless, Atlantic City casinos continue to be the driving force of the local economy. The resorts employed 23,000 people, paid $883 million in casino taxes and fees, purchased $605 million in goods and services from New Jersey vendors, invested $205 million into their properties, donated $1 million to charitable causes, and volunteered more than 7,000 hours. 

New York Looming 

By the time 2025 closes, it’s expected that the bidding war for the three downstate New York casino licenses will be finished. Each concession comes with a $500 million fee for the privilege of operating slot machines, live dealer table games, and retail sports betting in New York City, Long Island, or Westchester County.

Bokunewicz says the next few years are critical in solidifying Atlantic City’s standing in an ever-growing competitive landscape. NYC has for decades been a major feeder market for the New Jersey shore town.

The continued reinvestment and revitalization in our great city is more important than ever with the expansion of downstate New York casinos on the horizon,” she concluded.